When it comes to game design, there are differing opinions on the role of difficulty. FromSoftware president Hidetaka Miyazaki and Arrowhead Game Studios CCO Johan Pilestedt both emphasize the integral nature of challenge in the games they create. Miyazaki acknowledges that the difficulty in FromSoftwares’ games like Elden Ring is intentional, as he believes that overcoming challenges is what allows players to truly experience and appreciate the game. Pilestedt echoes this sentiment, asserting that “A game for everyone is a game for no one,” emphasizing the importance of catering to a specific audience rather than trying to appeal to a broad range of players.
One of the key points raised in the discussion is the emotional impact of overcoming difficult challenges in games. Twitch streamer Stormfall33’s elation at defeating the Shadow of the Erdtree boss Rellana 173 deaths into the DLC highlights the sense of accomplishment and satisfaction that comes from conquering a tough adversary. This emotional response is a crucial aspect of game design, as Pilestedt notes that good game design is about evoking emotions more than anything else. By presenting players with challenging obstacles, developers like FromSoftware and Arrowhead Game Studios aim to create experiences that are memorable and emotionally engaging.
While challenging games may not be everyone’s cup of tea, Pilestedt argues that it is important to cater to a specific audience rather than trying to please everyone. Not everyone may enjoy the punishing difficulty of games like Dark Souls or Elden Ring, but for those who appreciate a challenge, these games offer a unique and rewarding experience. By staying true to their vision and focusing on creating games that appeal to a niche audience, developers can create experiences that stand out and resonate with players on a deeper level.
The Importance of Variety in the Games Industry
Pilestedt’s comments also touch on the diversity of experiences available in the games industry today. With so many different types of games catering to various preferences and skill levels, players have a wide range of experiences to choose from. This variety allows individuals to find games that resonate with them personally, whether they enjoy challenging experiences like those offered by FromSoftware or prefer more casual and accessible games. By embracing this variety, developers can continue to push the boundaries of game design and offer innovative and engaging experiences to players of all backgrounds.
The debate over the role of difficulty in game design highlights the importance of creating experiences that resonate with players on an emotional level. Developers like FromSoftware and Arrowhead Game Studios understand the power of challenge in creating memorable and engaging experiences, and they are committed to catering to specific audiences rather than trying to please everyone. By embracing the diversity of experiences available in the games industry and staying true to their vision, developers can continue to push the boundaries of game design and offer unique and compelling experiences to players around the world.
Leave a Reply